Last comments Anicsi

Wow, the effects really really sort of epic. The way it was pieced together, the masking, digital effects and flow really added to the feeling of 'BAMM, in your face' xD Sorry, that explanation sucks *cough* haha, anyway, fantastic job! The only criticism I have is that the music conveys much more emotion than the video shows. You showed nothing but combat, but I think that there could have been more behind it to give it more depth. (If it has to be related to fighting, it could be the reason they're fighting, or the cause, or even the aftermath.) It got a bit repetitive after some time.
Either way, great job ^^ 5

Totally fell in love with this! So sad, but amazingly executed. Fantastic job!

Gotta say it again: You guys seriously rock. I'm not much a fan of that kind of music (or lyrics lol) but you actually edited this so well, that I had to watch it a few times. I loved the effects, all the masking, transitions, included text, all of which were creative, yet give off a sense of simplicity. Very well done ^^

Man, this was so fantastic. I loved it so much. Definitely my favorite of this contest. It was perfectly executed; the mood, the scenes, the editing - just so amazing. It could certainly become one of my favorite amvs ever.

Wow, fantastically edited. I don't even want to know how much time it took to mask and match all these scenes. I've watched the two main anime, so I could see all the changes you made, but otherwise i'd have thought them to be from one anime only. The story was conveyed so well and really touching, too. In a different mood, it might have made me cry. Definitely one of the best videos i've seen for the contest so far. Splendid work!

Wow, Andrew, that was amazing! To be honest, I was getting a bit sick of seeing madoka all over the place, but this is seriously one of the best videos with it I've seen. The theme was conveyed very well, and it seems you added underused footage, which is a big plus. Timing spot on of course, the effects subtle but befitting the mood - I just really loved it! It doesn't look rushed to me, better than many videos here I've seen so far xp Great job, I enjoyed it thoroughly. 5

Gidra wrote:
what a piece of vanilla shit

lol, That's the most constructive criticism I've ever gotten. Thanks ;)

Amazing job! Editing was superb, and even though it wasn't exactly original, it flowed so well and seamlessly that I gotta give you 5 :p Great job, seriously. Loved it!

That was pretty nice editing. Great scene choice, ominous feeling Just too bad there was no climax. I was sort of on edge, waiting for the music to go all crazy with loads of action and the 'big bang'. If there had been something like that i'm sure it could have become an epic video! Still, jood job! ^^

Kara no Kyoukai is one of my favorite Anime, so I was really looking forward to this one! Great editing, perfect timing, just sadly no story apparent. I think there could have been done more with that song and editing, while still keeping the Action in mind. Either way, great job, I liked it! ^^ 4

That was really pretty! I loved the mood and the idea with the pictures. Lovely scene choice and mostly good job with the scrap book design :D Sadly the masking was sloppy, and generally I think it would have come out better without effects apart from the book itself. Still, lovely video!! 4

The editing was really amazing! I know you pointed it out in your description, but yeah, I think it's only sad that you didn't quite follow any storyline or story concept. Quite a few anime were just thrown in because they looked pretty it seems. Maybe you should have sticked to knK only, or Anime of a similar genre. I am really impressed with the editing, though, I hope you'll make another video, just with a bit more thought behind it ^^

That was really awesome. Fantastic editing!

Wow, this was really amazing!! Sadly I didn't really like the song as much, but that's just a matter of tastes. It surely fit lyrically, and your editing was just so epic. I loved how you combined these two animes, that was really well done! Superb work, I'm impressed!! 5

Loved it ^^ It was really upbeat and catchy, also really funny at parts! Great job! 5