I need a friend

надо было бы убрать облачки со страниц, а то как то не так смотрится. В целом неплохо.

совсем не плохо,- даже хорошо.
можно было бы по экспериментировать с сочными картинками, как на 1.05 и музыку в титрах погромче

слишком огрызочно и неаккуратно. запомнились разве что открывающиеся глазки.
3

Leegf:

Ok, I'll keep my opinion to myself.
I just advice you to rethink your attitude. You won't succeed with it.

I know, I was too harsh and rude. I felt offended when I read all the negative comments and wanted to let off some steam.

I want to apologise to everyone!

farba:

Good, but, as you know there's an anime for this manga and
comparing with an episode(any) this amv is not that interesting
sorry for your hard work

I really like the anime, too, but the moments/pages/stories I used in my MMV aren't and won't be put in the anime this season. Except that, the manga then was really interesting and I wanted to use it.

Lirinis:

You could say you had a style if your works were distinguishable from myriads of others that try to follow the same cliche.

Um... I don't think you can find the same things that I've made but okay, this is your opinion and in my opinon the things I make aren't cliches.

Lirinis:

Not every opinion has to be pleasing and motivating. Deal with it.

I don't want it to pleasing, I just want it not to be rude/demotivationg: you can say if you like it or not/ what you liked or didn't like/ give an advide how to make it better next time.

Lirinis:

I've heard this soooo many times and it was never true. Don't lie to yourself. Everybody wants others to appreciate his work.

Well, I was planning this project a lot before the contest and I'm glad it was this contest which gave me some of the motivation I needed to finish it.

Lirinis:

Guess what? Friends never give honest opinions.

Look at the video on youtube: all of the comments (except 3-4) are from people I've never talked with. That means that not only my friends like it but also people I don't know.

Lirinis:

This is a contest. You put up your work – you ask for evaluation.

Well, to be honest you're right here. I just didn't expect such rudeness and as I said, I wanted to let off some steam.


I hope I answered everything I needed to and I tried not to be rude/offensive. I'm sorry again for the bad things I said before (though some of them are true) and please don't be rude when commenting. :)

Ok, I'll keep my opinion to myself.
I just advice you to rethink your attitude. You won't succeed with it.

Carpet-man:

Ну, как M@D - очень странный. Кусками сделан хорошо, а кусками просто отвратительно: особенно огромное увеличение на сканах плохого качества + не всегда был стерт текст с окошек + типографика так себе.

Как с языка сняли.
Автор, можно было хотя бы ради конкурса сканы почистить или найти хорошего качества?

Good, but, as you know there's an anime for this manga and
comparing with an episode(any) this amv is not that interesting
sorry for your hard work

Лично мне весь романтичный настрой испортил пузырь жвачки у парня на первых секундах (ассоциация вообще с насморком прошла). Имхо такие вещи отсекать нужно.
Сделано вроде вполне добротно.
Переход в цвет в самом конце понравился.

xVen:

I am an youtube editor

Easy to see. All sensitive and touchy. :-)

xVen:

This is my style

You could say you had a style if your works were distinguishable from myriads of others that try to follow the same cliche.

xVen:

demotivationg opinions

Not every opinion has to be pleasing and motivating. Deal with it.

xVen:

I didn't make this video for you to like it, I made it for myself and my friends

I've heard this soooo many times and it was never true. Don't lie to yourself. Everybody wants others to appreciate his work.

xVen:

my friends like it and that's all that matters to me

Guess what? Friends never give honest opinions.

xVen:

don't like it - don't watch it

xVen:

If you're gonna write bad comments, just don't

This is a contest. You put up your work – you ask for evaluation.

xVen, The whole point of participating in this kind of contests is to get your work judged by other people, who will give you their honest opinions (thus sometimes hard to accept).
Not sure what you expected

xVen: I am an youtube editor
Ясно.

Написал джели и бэд хьюман биинг.

I just want to say to all of you, who commented, that I am an youtube editor and this is the kind of videos I do and I enjoy. This is my style: don't like it - don't watch it! It's easy... you could've shut your mouth and keep your demotivationg opinions. I didn't make this video for you to like it, I made it for myself and my friends and guess what: I love the way it turned out and you are no one to tell me if the music/manga/fonts/whatever in the video is bad cause you will never be able to do things like this. I think you all have said that cause you're jelous or just bad people but my friends like it and that's all that matters to me.
P.S. If you're gonna write bad comments, just don't - keep your opinion for yourself...

Ужасный выбор песни, шрифта, да и сделано как-то.. слишком скучно. На ютубе таких клипов полно, мало кто из авторов может выделиться, сделать работу, которая бы задела. В основном это одни и те же приемы, один и тот же стиль. =/

Вот никак они не могут без текста обойтись.
/посмотрел на ютуб-канал автора/
Неужели самому не скучно годами в каждом своём клипе делать одно и то же? Причём не просто одно и тоже, но и то же самое, что делают сотни других ютубных мейкеров?

Хз. Слишком криво. СТандыртные эфекты. Все грубо. Бррр. Долго атвору точить скил.

Только начался разгон
Уже конец
---------
Напомнило короткий рекламный роли что ли
"Псомотрите на своего друга и не меня. Да, мне нужен друг"

Не воодушивило(( Вокал раздражал, да оборвалось все как-то.

I love it!

Eh, couldn't enjoy it and it seems really unfinished.

It was a good animation ! But I think the text was too present, too big and the police wasn't really nice. It's too bad, the rest is great!

great animations sadly didnt enjoy the texts and song

Ну, как M@D - очень странный. Кусками сделан хорошо, а кусками просто отвратительно: особенно огромное увеличение на сканах плохого качества + не всегда был стерт текст с окошек + типографика так себе.

Но, скорее, основной аспект моей очень бугуртной субъективной оценки, что из такой манги сделали такой клип. Это же такая романтика с этими вечными экспериментами, без толики моральных ценностей, мальчики с мальчиками, девочки с девочками, и все, чтобы просто протестить и использовать на максимум всю силу ведьм. А тут просто сентиментальщина между гг.

not bad xD . youtuber style xD